All reviews
Each review scores the formula on our 100-point methodology — formula quality, dosing, testing transparency, value and experience — with every material fact dated and sourced. Newest first.
Published
A genuinely well-dosed 10 g of Type I & III collagen — the powder itself is fine. The honest knocks are undocumented testing and an aggressive auto-ship and billing record.
Read the full reportA novel, convenient red-grape capsule with a disclosed 6 mg of piceid resveratrol — but a tiny dose whose claimed edge is company-funded, no third-party testing, and a hard-to-cancel subscription.
Read the full reportA differentiated women-specific organ blend, tested by a real lab — but a proprietary blend hides a tiny 337 mg dose, the iron claim doesn’t hold up, and the vitamin A goes unstated against explicit pregnancy marketing.
Read the full reportThe best of a weak field: the only NSF Certified for Sport beet product and the highest measured nitrate — but still underdosed and won’t print its number.
Read the full reportThe honest, cheap pick: 1,000 mg of beet root, conservative claims, ~22¢ a serving. Underdosed like all beet capsules — but doesn’t pretend otherwise.
Read the full reportSmart formula (organic beet + red spinach) undone by a proprietary blend that hides the one number that matters. Good ideas, hidden doses.
Read the full reportA tasty, cheap berry chew — but a 325 mg proprietary blend, undisclosed nitrate, and 2 g of added sugar in a “heart” product.
Read the full reportThe most-advertised beet in America — and independently measured at just ~64 mg nitrate, a fraction of the studied dose, at 7× the cost of bulk.
Read the full reportAn unremarkable beet capsule wrapped in an aggressive DTC funnel — ~348 BBB complaints and ~1,000 negative reviews over surprise recurring charges.
Read the full reportA clean 5 g of monohydrate, single ingredient, NSF Certified for Sport — the category’s #1. The premium done right.
Read the full report5 g monohydrate, NSF Certified for Sport — but it dropped Creapure for an in-house purity spec. The certified alternative.
Read the full reportThe same 5 g of pure monohydrate for half the price, with Informed Choice testing. The value default.
Read the full reportThe budget champion — 5 g at ~3–4¢ a gram. A tested-claim facility, not an athlete cert.
Read the full reportNSF-certified Creapure gummies — but under-dosed at 4.5 g, +sugar, and 6–8× the cost per gram.
Read the full reportA real 5 g of creatine bolted to weak-evidence HMB at 3–4× the price, with no named cert.
Read the full reportThe category winner: a sensible 2,000 IU of D3, USP Verified, at 13¢ a serving. Does the fundamentals right.
Read the full reportThe same sensible dose for ~7¢ a serving, GMP-audited. Cheapest that’s genuinely good.
Read the full report1,000 IU D3 + 200 mcg K2 in a dropper, NSF-tested. The best combo/liquid pick, if you want K2.
Read the full reportClean, cheap, NSF Contents Certified — but 5,000 IU is a deficiency-correction dose, not everyday.
Read the full reportA conservative 1,000 IU in olive oil — nice, but ~10× the price per unit of the mass-market bottles.
Read the full reportThe vegan pick (lichen D3 + MK-7) — but 5,000 IU over the limit, unnamed testing, and the priciest here.
Read the full reportThe category winner: 200 mg elemental as glycinate, USP Verified, and the cheapest real glycinate. It does the fundamentals right.
Read the full reportSame sensible 200 mg glycinate with NSF Certified for Sport — the gold-standard mark. The certified pick, at a premium.
Read the full reportThe budget champion: 200 mg glycinate chelate for about 16¢ a serving. No named cert is the only real knock.
Read the full reportThe label lesson: “2,000 mg Magtein” is only ~145 mg elemental. A well-made, pricey, brain-targeted niche.
Read the full reportThe fizzy magnesium drink — citrate at 325 mg, near the upper limit and laxative. Fine if you titrate the dose.
Read the full report“7 forms” — but a proprietary blend hides how much of each, 500 mg exceeds the upper limit, and the pricing is an anchor.
Read the full reportA rare clean gummy: sugar-free, 7 g fiber, and a fully disclosed immune blend. It out-scored our own brand’s products — and we say so.
Read the full reportA genuinely novel sprinkle-on FODMAP enzyme. Real peer-reviewed mechanism and Monash certification, held back by price and no placebo-controlled trial yet.
Read the full reportDiscloses an 852 mg beta-sitosterol dose — 6–14× studied amounts — but buries the rest in proprietary blends behind a self-referential “#1 rated” funnel.
Read the full reportDiscloses its doses (a real plus) but underdoses the joint claim and auto-ships you from a $19.95 trial to ~$85 a month.
Read the full reportLegit branded ingredients — each dosed at about one-third of its own clinical studies. No product-level certification.
Read the full reportA 2-strain synbiotic whose CFU count isn’t even on the label (~2 billion), doses buried in blends, sold on aggressive auto-ship.
Read the full reportA green-lipped-mussel oil delivering only ~34 mg of omega-3 per serving — roughly 1–3% of a studied dose — at a premium price.
Read the full reportA full gram of sodium, NSF Certified for Sport, zero sugar — the best-verified electrolyte we’ve scored. Yes, it beat our own brand’s product.
Read the full reportThe category’s best zero-sugar value — outscored by LMNT on our own rubric, and the review says so by name. That’s the site working.
Read the full reportThe cheapest sticker in the category is the priciest zero-sugar sodium per milligram. The gym-bag classic, honestly measured.
Read the full reportThe realest ingredient list in the category — and 100 mg of sodium, its smallest dose. We bought the box and photographed the label.
Read the full reportThe “Cellular Transport Technology” is real — it’s 11 grams of sugar. A good acute-dehydration tool sold as a daily habit.
Read the full reportOur owner’s other company, scored with the same ruler: the only label stating dose, IgG and a named standard — and a return policy we call out plainly.
Read the full reportAll 11 amounts printed — unique in its category — and we say in our own review that 600 mg is a modest dose. That’s the point.
Read the full reportThe category’s biggest disclosed scoop — 3 g, printed — and no IgG number anywhere on it. We bought it and photographed the label.
Read the full reportThe brand that built the category won’t state its serving weight or IgG — and carries an F at the BBB. The $119.99 jar, examined.
Read the full reportThe likeable farm brand claims the field’s highest IgG — 40% of a serving weight we had to buy the jar to learn. The honest math, now label-verified.
Read the full reportThe $29.99 Target tub is 79% collagen — the label says so, honestly. Per gram of actual colostrum, it’s the priciest option here.
Read the full reportNSF-certified with 33 company-funded trials — and not one disclosed plant amount. The best label in the TV-capsule category, scored honestly.
Read the full reportThe TV-famous capsules with no ingredient amounts disclosed, an FDA warning-letter history and $89.99/month pricing. We did the math the ads don’t.
Read the full reportA quantified gummy multivitamin priced like premium greens — with 35 superfoods hidden in a 6.7 g blend and a 2025 Prop 65 lead notice on the kids’ line. We bought the box.
Read the full reportBeckham’s all-in-one is the best-certified in the category (NSF Certified for Sport) — and still hides its superfood, amino and adaptogen doses behind proprietary blends.
Read the full reportAn unusually honest single-ingredient capsule built on an unusually early idea — C15:0 isn’t recognized as essential, and the pivotal trials are small and company-linked.
Read the full report150 ingredients on the label — 31 mg for all seventeen herbs combined, B12 at 25,000% of the Daily Value, and no named testing standard. The radio-famous multi, divided.
Read the full reportEvery ingredient amount printed — the disclosure we ask for — at a modest ~1 g collagen dose. Common ownership disclosed.
Read the full reportA fully disclosed MSM/boswellia/turmeric joint stack — supportive doses, every amount printed. Common ownership disclosed.
Read the full reportThe most disclosed reds powder we’ve scored — beet, hibiscus, berries and probiotics, nearly every amount printed. Common ownership disclosed.
Read the full reportA clean single-source 20 g protein — non-GMO verified — with wellness claims that outrun the bone-broth evidence.
Read the full reportA research-level 20 g collagen dose from five sources — grouped in one complex, with egg and fish allergens.
Read the full reportThe best-tested greens powder we’ve scored — NSF Certified for Sport, most comprehensive formula — and the priciest, behind a proprietary blend.
Read the full reportA genuine 550 mg zero-sugar sodium dose, fully printed — undercut by a light mineral ratio and a near-$2 serving.
Read the full reportThe cleanest real-fruit label and the field’s best magnesium — carrying its lightest sodium at its highest price.
Read the full reportThe cheaper AG1 alternative — a real 8 g scoop at a friendlier price, behind proprietary blends and an unnamed testing claim.
Read the full reportA rare produce capsule that prints its amounts — which is how you learn it’s a token 600 mg dose, untested by any named program.
Read the full reportA bit more produce powder than most capsules (~2.8 g) — behind proprietary blend totals, no named testing and anchored pricing.
Read the full reportA “GLP-1 support” capsule riding the Ozempic wave — markets berberine, akkermansia and fucoxanthin but discloses none of their doses.
Read the full reportEach report takes days of label analysis, cost math and record-checking — we publish when the work is done, not on a content calendar.
In the pipeline
Reports in active research. No link until it’s published — we don’t do placeholder pages.
Formula 25 · Dosage 20 · Testing 20 · Value 15 · Experience 10 · Brand 10. The rubric is public and applies to every product — including those from Earth Energy Supplements, an independently operated company under common ownership with this site. Read the methodology.
No sponsored scores, no pay-for-placement, no deleting negative findings. Links to products we have no relationship with are plain Google searches that earn us nothing. Editorial policy · How we make money.
